Welcome to Siesta Key, where the freshest catches of the sea meet the inviting charm of our coastal dining scene. In this guide, we’re excited to take you on a culinary journey through six of the best seafood spots on Siesta Key. From succulent shrimp to mouthwatering lobster, these restaurants offer a taste of the ocean that will leave you craving more.
And when you’re enjoying the best seafood in Siesta Key, consider calling one of our Siesta Key vacation condos your home away from home.
Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar
Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar is a local eatery based along the Florida Gulf, offering an exceptional dining experience that celebrates the bounty of the sea and the chefs who prepare the meals. Whether you’re craving fresh cocktails, delectable appetizers, or mouthwatering entrees, this inviting seafood sanctuary is bound to exceed your expectations.
Start your meal with their famous clam chowder, a creamy delight that has won numerous awards and is sure to whet your appetite. For the main course, the fresh crab legs and juicy oysters are a must-try, delivering the perfect combination of flavor and freshness. If you’re in the mood for something different, their shrimp scampi and blackened grouper sandwich are also crowd favorites.
With a wide array of freshly caught Gulf fish, fried seafood, and non-seafood items, there’s truly something for every palate. As you savor your meal, don’t forget to pair it with a refreshing cocktail from their extensive menu. The welcoming ambiance, family-friendly menu, and live music on select evenings create an unforgettable dining experience.
Siesta Key Oyster Bar
A visit to Siesta Key wouldn’t be complete without a stop at the beloved Siesta Key Oyster Bar, affectionately known as SKOB. Nestled in the heart of Siesta Key Village, SKOB is a lively hotspot known for its vibrant atmosphere, friendly service, and, of course, exceptional seafood.
The star of the menu is undoubtedly the oysters. Whether you prefer them raw, steamed, or Rockefeller-style, SKOB delivers fresh, flavorful options that will satisfy any oyster aficionado. For those looking to explore beyond oysters, the menu offers a variety of delectable dishes, such as the succulent lobster roll, crispy fish tacos, and the ever-popular shrimp and grits.
One of the unique features of SKOB is its casual, laid-back vibe that invites you to kick back and relax. Enjoy live music on the outdoor patio, where you can soak up the island ambiance and mingle with locals and fellow travelers. Happy hour at SKOB is not to be missed, offering great deals on drinks and oysters that make it the perfect spot to unwind after a day at the beach.
Whether you’re a seafood lover or simply looking for a fun place to hang out, Siesta Key Oyster Bar promises an unforgettable dining experience.
The Old Salty Dog Siesta Key
For a true taste of coastal cuisine and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, head over to The Old Salty Dog on Siesta Key. Situated just steps from the water, this iconic eatery offers a relaxed, family-friendly setting perfect for enjoying some of the island’s best seafood.
A highlight of The Old Salty Dog’s menu is the famous “Salty Dog,” a quarter-pound hot dog dipped in beer batter and fried to crispy perfection. While it’s a must-try, the seafood options are equally enticing. Indulge in their fresh fish and chips, peel-and-eat shrimp, or the hearty seafood platter featuring a generous selection of the ocean’s finest.
The Old Salty Dog also offers a variety of daily specials and an extensive drink menu that pairs perfectly with their seaside fare. Whether you’re in the mood for a cold beer, a signature cocktail, or a refreshing glass of wine, there’s something for everyone to enjoy!
Plan Your Next Visit
Are you ready to find your new favorite restaurant in Siesta Key? Browse our selection of Siesta Key vacation rentals today and find the perfect match for your stay!
The Cottage
Immerse yourself in an eclectic dining experience at The Cottage, a culinary haven located in the heart of Siesta Key Village. Celebrating the fusion of global flavors, fresh local seafood, and innovative cooking techniques, The Cottage promises a dining adventure like no other.
With a diverse Tapas menu boasting delights like Salmon Tartar and Black Mussels, seafood lovers will find their cravings met with the freshest ingredients and an array of flavors. Opt for the Lobster Maki Sushi entree for a more traditional dining experience that seamlessly intertwines custom with modern culinary artistry.
Pair your meal with one of The Cottage’s expertly crafted cocktails or a selection from their extensive wine list. The friendly and attentive staff are always on hand to ensure your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional.
Summer House Steak and Seafood
At Summer House Steak and Seafood, the art of Surf and Turf takes center stage, promising a symphony of flavors that captivate the senses. With a rich history of crafting memorable dining experiences in Siesta Key, this establishment is synonymous with the culinary excellence one would expect from a Siesta Key eatery.
Start your culinary journey with the Ahi Tuna Tartare, a refreshing appetizer that showcases the delicate flavors of sushi-grade tuna complemented by avocado and a zesty citrus dressing. For the main course, the Chilean Sea Bass is a standout, known for its buttery texture and served with a flavorful miso glaze. If you prefer something from the land, the USDA Prime steaks are tender and juicy, offering a satisfying alternative to seafood. If you still have room after your meal, be sure to check out our top picks for the best coffee and dessert spots near Siesta Key!
Lobster Pot Restaurant
Embark on a culinary journey that pays homage to rich culinary heritages at Lobster Pot Restaurant. With roots dating back to 1940 in Cape Cod, this establishment seamlessly blends Portuguese, New England, and Florida influences to create an excellent menu!
At the Lobster Pot, the highlight is undoubtedly the Maine lobster. Whether you prefer it steamed, stuffed, or baked, each preparation showcases the delicious flavors that lobster lovers crave. The Lobster Pot Pie, brimming with tender lobster, vegetables, and a creamy sauce encased in a flaky crust, is a crowd favorite. For a different take, try the Lobster Mac and Cheese, which combines rich, cheesy goodness with generous chunks of lobster.
The menu also features a variety of other seafood delights, including New England Clam Chowder, perfectly fried clam strips, and the Seafood Sampler, which offers a taste of the ocean with shrimp, scallops, and fish. If you’re in the mood for something beyond seafood, the restaurant also offers delicious steaks, chicken dishes, and vegetarian options.
Book Your Siesta Key Condo Rental with Crystal Sands
As you embark on a culinary adventure through the savory seafood spots of Siesta Key, allow Crystal Sands Condominiums to be your haven of luxury and comfort. With our Siesta Key beachfront condo rentals, your vacation experience is elevated to unparalleled heights, ensuring that every moment is filled with relaxation, indulgence, and an unmistakable sense of satisfaction. From the shimmering turquoise waters to the pristine white sand beaches, your stay at Crystal Sands promises to be nothing short of extraordinary.
Book your Siesta Key condo rental with Crystal Sands today and experience the best of island living! Your memorable stay awaits—discover why Siesta Key is a beloved destination for seafood lovers and beach enthusiasts alike.
