Find the Best Burger in Siesta Key on Your Next Visit

Siesta Key is home to turquoise water and white sand beaches. What’s better than staying in a Siesta Key beachfront rental and enjoying breathtaking views? And what vacation wouldn’t be complete without a little food tour? If you’re looking for amazing lunch options in some of the best burgers Siesta Key has to offer, here’s our list of the top 5 Siesta Key restaurants!

The Cottage

This Siesta Key burger restaurant is perfect if you’re looking for some mouthwatering food and delicious cocktails. Built with an island atmosphere, The Cottage has that “old Florida charm” but with a twist. They have some of the most progressive dining techniques sampled from around the world. The Cottage offers one of the best burgers on Siesta Key with their Billionaire Burger. They also offer their signature Chicken Sandwich and a full menu of soups and salads. Stop by The Cottage and enjoy the live music hosted daily!

Sun Garden Cafe

woman eating a burger at siesta key restaurant

Are you looking for an award-winning breakfast and lunch cafe? How about some good food with a casual, family-friendly atmosphere? The Sun Garden Cafe offers all this and so much more! Everything on their menu is grown and raised in the area. You’re getting the freshest “farm-to-table” menu items. Sarasota has rated them “the best breakfast, best lunch, best outdoor dining, and best bacon” in the Siesta Key area! The Sun Garden serves breakfast all day. If you’re searching for a delectable breakfast fit for a king late at night, they have it for you! But, if you’re looking for the best burger in Siesta Key, then stop by for one of their burgers based on your favorite rockers! Try their Bob Dylan, a curry rubbed burger with sweet pickles, cheddar, and so much bacon!

Village Café

Another stop on your Siesta Key restaurant tour should be the Village Café! Started in 1995, this restaurant has been a staple to the Siesta Key area. This family-owned, casual café offers a beautiful, beachy atmosphere. The vibes are perfect for the whole family. If you’re looking for a restaurant located right in the heart of America’s #1 beach, the Village Cafe is the place to be! When you stop in for a bite to eat, you have to try their Belly Bustin’ Burgers! They have an extensive burger menu. Fries and chips can also be added to your order as well.

The Hub Baja Grill

Whether you’re a tourist or a local, The Hub Baja Grill is the perfect place for Baja cuisine. The Hub has become most famous for their Grouper fish tacos, hand-made lobster bisque, and other Latin American-inspired dishes. The Hub also has beautiful outdoor dining seats, so you can look out at Siesta Key. Bask in the Gulf Coast weather while you enjoy your Baja-inspired meal. Sample some of their finely crafted cocktails while diving into their seafood-inspired menus.

Island House Tap & Grill

Are you a big fan of pairing your dinners with a nice pint of something strong? The Island House Tap and Grill know that enjoyment all too well! They carry an extensive list of craft beers on draft for your sipping pleasure. Whether you’re looking for a snack or a meal, they’re the perfect place to pair a drink with. When you stop at the Island House, you have a menu of some of the best burgers in Siesta Key. You can try their Merica Burger, a burger crafted with Beecher’s flagship cheddar, and their ½ pound of black Angus beef. You can sink your teeth into their Hangover burger for those nights you’ve had a little too much.

Plan Your Next Stay

Ready to book your Siesta Key getaway? Crystal Sands offers the best selection of Siesta Key beachfront condo rentals. What are you waiting for? Let us help you plan your Siesta Key vacation. Contact us today!

Where to stay?

When you decide to book your Siesta Key vacation, the Crystal Sands is the perfect place for you to stay. We offer some of the finest Siesta Key condo rentals on the strip! Each room overlooks the beach and the Gulf of Mexico. You can lounge out on your patio and take in the salty sea air. Our hotel and villas are two miles away from all shops and restaurants like the ones with the best burgers! The Crystal Sands on Siesta Key is perfect for a retreat with your loved one or a family beach trip.


Our Location

Crystal Sands Condominiums
6300 Midnight Pass Road
Siesta Key, FL 34242

Toll-Free: 888-419-1446
Local: 941-349-7007

Fax: 941-346-1963

Stay Connected


  • NAME
  • JOIN OUR NEWS LETTER!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.