Check Out the Best Ice Cream Shops in Siesta Key!

Siesta Key is more than just a picturesque destination with white sandy beaches and crystal-clear waters. It’s also home to an array of dining options, including uniquely delicious ice cream shops.

Jake’s Ice Cream

Jake’s Ice Cream, located on the southern end of Siesta Key, provides a range of flavors that appeal to classic tastes and adventurous palates. This local favorite prides itself on using only the finest ingredients to produce hand-crafted ice cream that consistently earns rave reviews. The high quality of Jake’s ice cream is evident in every spoonful of their delicious, homemade flavors.

Families, friends, and individuals exploring Siesta Key restaurants will find Jake’s Ice Cream a perfect spot for a sweet treat after their meal. The welcoming atmosphere, coupled with extraordinary customer service, makes it an ideal destination for locals and tourists alike. Whether you are looking to enjoy a scoop of traditional vanilla or a unique flavor, Jake’s Ice Cream guarantees to provide a taste that enhances your Siesta Key experience.

Made In Rome Organic Gelato

Another great ice cream shop in Siesta Key is Made In Rome Organic Gelato. Situated in Siesta Key Village, Made In Rome takes pride in offering authentic Italian gelato using 100% organic ingredients. Each small batch of organic gelato is carefully crafted with fresh ingredients, ensuring that each serving stands out in quality and flavor.

The allure of this gelato shop lies not only in the taste but also in the passion put into every batch. Guests can relish the genuine Italian experience without leaving the island. Made In Rome Organic Gelato offers a delicious alternative to traditional ice cream. This makes it one of the best ice cream shops in Siesta Key for those seeking quality and variety.

Orange Octopus

Orange Octopus is renowned for its delightful variety of hand-scooped ice cream and its whimsical beach-themed ambiance. As part of Captain Curt’s Village, it offers visitors an all-day experience. Enjoy your morning coffee, savor dinner at one of the top restaurants in Siesta Key, and, our course, end the day with a cup or cone of delicious ice cream. 

What sets Orange Octopus apart is the dedication to fresh ingredients and creative flavors. Both locals and vacationers can appreciate the craftsmanship and creativity that define Orange Octopus, making it a cornerstone in the search for the best ice cream Siesta Key has to offer.

Olaf’s Ice Cream Shop

Established in 1982, Olaf’s Ice Cream Shop has been a beloved part of Siesta Village for over four decades. Family-owned and operated, Olaf’s offers delicious cones, sundaes, milkshakes, malts, smoothies, and fudge. The cornerstone of their offering is Yoder’s Southern Creamery ice cream, which is produced locally in Sarasota.

Olaf’s has been a favorite for both locals and visitors for many generations. Enjoy a trip down memory lane with rich, old-fashioned flavors or try something new. If you’re staying at our Siesta Key vacation rentals, Olaf’s is a convenient spot to satisfy your sweet tooth.  

Abel’s Ice Cream

Abel’s Ice Cream, known for featuring over 40 flavors of Florida-made, award-winning ice cream, is the place to go for quality and creativity. From the Stellar Coffee flavor to crowd favorites like Caramel Caribou and Raspberry Truffle, Abel’s selection is an exploration of taste that caters to all preferences.

Founded by Bill and Norma Abel in 2011, Abel’s is dedicated to bringing the best ice cream, chocolates, and gourmet products to Sarasota. In addition to ice cream, guests can enjoy hand-made chocolates by Sweet Shop USA, Sarasota roasted LeLu Island Coffee, and Sarasota’s own Tropical Shores Popcorn.

Kilwins Ice Cream

Since 1947, Kilwins has been a celebrated part of the American ice cream tradition, earning a reputation for high-quality products and excellent service. Kilwins combines the finest ingredients with time-honored recipes, creating confections that are both decadent and satisfying. Visitors can expect a sweet experience with high-quality ice cream and customer service.

Kilwins continues to uphold its tradition of excellence through a community of caring franchisees who deliver exceptional products consistently. Its blend of superior ice cream and community-oriented service makes Kilwins one of the best dessert spots near Siesta Key.

Book Your Siesta Key Condo Rental with Crystal Sands

When planning your Siesta Key vacation, staying at one of our Siesta Key vacation condos will ensure easy access to these top-tier ice cream shops. The comfort and convenience of our Siesta Key vacation condos amplify the overall experience, allowing you to indulge in both high-quality accommodations and frozen treats. At Crystal Sands, we provide a range of Siesta Key condo rentals that cater to varying needs and preferences. Whether you are seeking a relaxing beachfront vacation rental in Siesta Key or a family-friendly rental with all amenities, Crystal Sands promises a memorable stay. By choosing Crystal Sands, visitors can enhance their trip with comfortable accommodations while exploring the best ice cream Siesta Key has to offer.

Each ice cream shop mentioned delivers unique offerings that embody the spirit and flavor of Siesta Key. From family traditions and organic options to innovative recipes, the ice cream shops on Siesta Key have something for everyone. Enjoying ice cream in Siesta Key is more than just a treat—it’s a memorable experience that complements the beauty of the island. The diversity of ice cream shops in Siesta Key ensures that every visit is filled with delightful options and unforgettable flavors. As you enjoy your stay in Siesta Key 4-bedroom vacation rentals, don’t miss the opportunity to explore these fantastic ice cream destinations.