The Best Coffee & Dessert Spots Near Siesta Key

Siesta Key is a popular destination where beautiful Florida beaches and laid-back island living come together for the perfect vacation spot. At Crystal Sands Condominiums, we pride ourselves on providing the ultimate beachfront getaway, offering Siesta Key condo rentals that are a true testament to comfort and relaxation. And when it comes to exploring the irresistible flavors of Siesta Key, you’re in for a treat.

The best Siesta Key restaurants are just moments away from our vacation condos. Join us as we embark on a culinary adventure to discover the best coffee and dessert spots near downtown Siesta Key restaurants!

Orange Octopus

Orange Octopus is a family-owned ice cream shop in Siesta Key that redefines ice cream. Orange Octopus takes pride in offering a premium ice cream that is truly unparalleled. They are not just another chain; they are a family-run business driven by a passion for creating extraordinary artisanal ice cream that will leave a lasting impression. What sets their ice cream apart is the meticulous detail and care they put into each and every batch. Handmade and slow-churned on-site, using only the finest ingredients, their premium ice cream is a work of art. Savor flavors like Ooey Gooey Brownie, a decadent creation melding rich chocolate ice cream and chunks of brownie. Indulge in a scoop or two, and let yourself be swept away by the delicious array of flavors that Orange Octopus has in store for you.

Made in Rome Organic Gelato

Discover the flavors of Italy on Siesta Key at Made in Rome Organic Gelato, a small, unassuming gelateria that offers a true taste of Roman indulgence. Located in Siesta Key Village, Made in Rome Organic Gelato proudly serves the best Italian gelato in Siesta Key, transporting you to the bustling streets of Rome one spoonful at a time. What sets their gelato apart is an unwavering dedication to quality and tradition. They take organic milk, cream, eggs, sugar, fruits, and nuts and combine them using traditional Italian gelato techniques in small batches. The result is a truly exceptional gelato that is unrivaled in taste and texture. One flavor that will leave a lasting impression is the Pane, Burro e Marmellata, a unique creation that perfectly captures the essence of bread, butter, and jam. 

Clarabell Cookies

Indulge your sweet tooth and immerse yourself in a world of cookies at Clarabell Cookies. This family-owned bakery believes in using only the highest quality, natural ingredients to create cookies that are nothing short of extraordinary. With pure butter, real vanilla, and premium chocolate at the heart of every recipe, each bite of their handcrafted cookies is bound to impress. From classic favorites like Chocolate Chip and Snickerdoodle to unique creations like Cinnamon Roll and Peanut Butter Chip Brownie, Clarabell Cookies is your one-stop destination for all things cookie in Siesta Key. Treat yourself to a single cookie or order three dozen to share with friends and family. No matter how you choose to enjoy them, we guarantee that each bite will be better than the last.

Meaney’s Mini Donuts

For a unique dessert experience, a visit to Meaney’s Mini Donuts is an absolute must. Located in Siesta Key Village, this walk-up window donut shop will capture your heart with its perfectly formed, bite-sized delights. Watch as mini doughnuts roll off an assembly line and into a fryer. A skillful doughnut attendant scoops them out of the piping-hot oil and coats them in your choice of delectable toppings. The result is a light and irresistibly delicious mini doughnut that will have you coming back for more. Among the crowd-pleasing flavors at Meaney’s, the Strawberry Cheesecake stands out, featuring a delicate balance of cream cheese frosting and strawberry jam. Whether enjoyed as a sweet breakfast treat or as a delightful dessert while exploring Siesta Key, these mini doughnuts are sure to put a smile on your face. Meaney’s Mini Donuts has become a beloved local staple, satisfying the cravings of Siesta Key’s residents and visitors alike.

Village Cafe

Since 1995, Village Cafe has been a beloved gathering spot for coffee lovers seeking the perfect cup of coffee and a hearty breakfast. As a family-owned and operated establishment, they have built a reputation for providing a warm and inviting atmosphere where every guest feels like family. Their mission is simple: to create a cheerful family atmosphere with the friendliest staff and the greatest coffee to ensure that you feel right at home. At Village Cafe, convenience and quality are at the heart of everything they do. Their skilled baristas excel in the art of coffee-making, serving up a range of delightful options from strong espressos to smooth cappuccinos. Pair your expertly crafted coffee with one of their mouthwatering breakfast dishes, and you’re day will be off to a great start.

The Clever Cup Coffee Shop

Located in downtown Siesta Key, The Clever Cup Coffee Shop has been delighting Sarasota with organic, locally roasted coffee, tea, and specialty drinks since 2016. Step inside, and you’ll immediately feel the welcoming ambiance that makes it a second home for coffee lovers, artists, musicians, students, and everyone in between. Savor handcrafted beverages made with fair trade organic coffees sourced from Black Gold Coffee Roasters. Sit down with your favorite book, savor a delectable pastry, and let the intoxicating aroma of freshly brewed coffee envelop you. The Clever Cup was honored with the Sarasota Magazine’s Best Coffee Shop of 2019, a testament to their commitment to quality and excellence. And if you find yourself falling in love with a particular coffee blend, fear not, for The Clever Cup also offers their coffee beans for sale!

Captain Curt’s Coffee Shop

Experience the beauty of Siesta Key at Captain Curt’s Coffee Shop, located in the corner of Captain Curt’s Village. As a full-service café located on the south end of Siesta Key, this lesser-known coffee spot offers a laid-back atmosphere perfect for enjoying a cup of coffee under the covered outdoor Tiki Hut seating. Considered one of the best-kept secrets on the south end of the Key, Captain Curt’s Coffee Shop is the ideal spot to unwind and immerse yourself in a quiet moment of relaxation.

Book Your Stay With Crystal Sands 

After indulging in the extraordinary flavors of Siesta Key’s best coffee and dessert spots, retreat to the comfort and luxury of Crystal Sands Condominiums to relax and rejuvenate. Our Siesta Key vacation condos offer a beachfront experience defined by unparalleled luxury and convenience. From the moment you step onto our property, you will be greeted with warm hospitality, ensuring that your every need is met. At Crystal Sands, we take tremendous pride in constantly improving our facilities and amenities to exceed your expectations. The breathtaking white sand beaches and glistening turquoise waters serve as the perfect backdrop for a truly unforgettable vacation experience. Book your stay with Crystal Sands, and let us become your home away from home as you explore the richness and beauty of Siesta Key. Join our ever-growing family and experience the magic of Crystal Sands Condominiums.